Canope (Preludes, Book II, 1913)

(Here are my thoughts about playing this piece. Please add your thoughts in the comments at the bottom.)

This piece is pure Debussy – a beautiful, quiet contemplative tone poem.  Like “Des pas sur la neige” (Footprints in the Snow) from the first book of preludes, it is not terribly technically challenging, but it must be played with careful attention to every note to succeed.

While Canope has superficially very simple melodies and structure, this masks a very subtle harmonic structure and a complex exploration of sonorities. Claudio Arrau considered it to be one of Debussy’s greatest preludes and said “It’s miraculous that he created, in so few notes, this kind of depth.” (quoted in Roberts, p. 281)

Paul Roberts has a thorough and enlightening discussion of this piece in his book Images, which was my primary source for the connection with Javanese gamelan music described below.

From Schmitz, pp. 181-182: Canope refers to a type burial urn or jar from the city of Canope in Egypt: “Very simple in line, these jars bear no ornaments, and the sculptured head that covers them has a nearly stylized classical simplicity.”

Canopic jars from the 18th Dynasty

Though Canope is in Egypt, Debussy’s Canope is strongly influenced by Javanese gamelan music.  In a letter to the poet Pierre Louys in 1895 (reprinted in Debussy Letters), Debussy said “Remember the music of Java which contained every nuance, even the ones we no longer have names for.  There tonic and dominant had become empty shadows of use only to stupid children.”  There is very little sign of tonic and dominant in this piece.

Emotional Content: This piece, marked “very calm and gently sad” at the opening, is very quiet and contemplative.  It is evocative of an eastern ritual, with a hint of sensuousness.  Though there is very little overt emotional dynamics in this piece (animation at m. 17 and climaxes of a sort at mm. 24 and 28), Canope is evocative of vast emotion.

Shape and Flow: Superficially, Canope is composed of three simple motifs: Motif A is the parallel chords of the opening with the bass echo in m. 5. Motif B is the simple melody in mm. 7-10, and motif C is the short melody line in mm. 11-12.  The structure of the piece is then something like ABCDBEAC, where D and E are non-melodic interludes.  In other words at this level it is difficult to see a natural structure in this piece. This type of analysis does not really contribute to understanding Canope.

As Roberts points out, the key to understanding Canope is seeing it as a direct homage to the Javanese gamelan.  The gamelan ensemble has a bass gong whose overtones include all the notes that are played by the other instruments.  Then the structures like the non-harmonic chords followed by melody in motifs B and C, for example in mm. 7 and 11, can be seen as in imitation of the gamelan gong followed by a melody including the high overtones. From this perspective the percussive nature of motif B and C are natural, since the gamelan ensemble is composed of percussion instruments.  Even motif A can be seen as a quiet percussive melody.  The interludes in mm. 14-19 and mm. 24-25 can be understood as direct imitations of gamelan instruments.

To quote Roberts (after a discussion of mm 24-25 on p.165): “Only by imagining these sounds on eastern instruments, and the physical sensations involved, can a pianist do justice to Debussy’s demands.  There is little in the traditional nineteenth-century piano repertoire that can help us.”

But of course Canope does not sound anything at all like Javanese gamelan music.  Debussy used his experience of gamelan music to inspire a new way of thinking about music and sound.  The result is this beautiful, gentle prelude.

Another perspective on the shape of this piece occurs to me: the opening theme (mm. 1-6) are in an almost conventional dorian mode with an interesting modulation in the middle.  But then we have an exotic, almost independent gamelan-like piece breaking in suddenly at m. 7 and ending somewhat climatically at m. 25.  This is followed by a restatement of our dorian opening theme, modulating into a echo (dream? memory?) of the gamelan theme.  Almost as if Debussy wrote the gamelan-inspired center section independently, but then felt he had to wrap it in a gentle introduction and exit…Don’t take this too seriously – it’s probably a crackpot idea.

Perhaps the best way to understand this piece is to listen to a good recording.  I’m partial to Paul Jacob’s interpretation.


mm. 1 – 4 (marked “very calm and gently sad”): I play the opening chords slowly, gently and quietly, but without the soft pedal in order to maintain clarity.  I use full damper pedal, changing on each chord with a very slight overlap. This gives a resonance to the chords.  There is both a harmonic and a dynamic mini-climax m. 3, where the left hand should sound clearly but not louder than the right-hand chords.

mm. 5-6: I catch the pianissimo opening chord in m. 5 with the damper pedal, which I hold for the rest of the measure then half-pedal the bass notes in m. 6.  I play the bass octaves with both hands.  Be sure to keep both measures pianissimo.

mm. 7-10: Notice that the A in the bass is piano, while the following chord is pianissimoSchmitz, p 182, points out that the bass A is part of the phrase from the previous measure and should be played that way.  The chord almost breaks into that phrase, heralding the new, exotic melody.  The melody is piano and is played percussively, but with the damper pedal held throughout the measure.  I slowly release the damper pedal in m. 8, as indicated by the rests, by half-pedaling on the first notes, then fully changing pedal on the E-flat.  M. 9 and 10 are similar, with the pedal released somewhat earlier.  I play the octaves  with both hands.  M. 10 ends with a climax leading to the next motif.

You might object that there is no slur on the staccato notes in mm. 7 and 9.  But in my original edition facsimile it is marked to play some of the notes in the melody with the left hand while holding the left-hand chords at least one measure.  The only way this can be done is to hold the sustain pedal throughout the measure.  I therefore interpret the staccato markings as indicating a percussive, bell-like touch, which is what they usually mean when there is a slur.

mm. 11-13: I hold the chords in these measures with my hands while playing the melody and half-pedaling as needed to avoid too much mud without losing the resonance.  Again I take the staccato marking to indicate a bell-like sound, which makes a nice articulation contrasting the two high B-flat notes in mm. 11 and 13.

mm. 14-15: I’m not sure what to make of these measures: they contain the gong-like harmonically complex chords similar to the previous measures, but the melody suddenly has a distinctly French romantic feel.  It’s almost like waking up in the middle of a gamelan concert and realizing you are actually still in France.  I play them pretty much as written, holding the right-hand chord while playing the melody, and holding the left-hand chords throughout.  Sustain pedal mostly down with changes as required for clarity.

mm. 16-19: Then high percussive notes pull us back into the exotic music.  I think these measures would be utterly mysterious without thinking of a percussion ensemble.  Though percussive, these measures are still very quiet, almost in the distance.  I press the soft pedal at the beginning of m. 17 and release it at the end of m. 19.  Things are happening: m. 17 is marked “gradually more animated”.  Note that in m. 18 the chord is piano while the bass note is pianissimo, the opposite of before.

mm. 22-23: Very similar to mm. 7-10, except the chords have dynamic emphasis over the bass note.  I interpret the pianissimo to apply to the bass note only, so the melody is piano.  I hold the G octave throughout the measures while playing the melody with both hands, as usual half-pedaling as required to avoid mud.  Again this section ends in a climax leading to…

mm. 24-25: Roberts (p. 165) points our that there is an instrument in gamelan orchestra which plays a 7-note glissando, and this is probably what Debussy had in mind in these measures.  The C and E-flat octaves suggest small oriental cymbals or chimes.  Therefore this interlude is a quiet percussive climax.  Roberts suggests holding the sustain pedal throughout each of these measures, which would be faithful to the gamelan sound.  I think it also works to change the pedal at the A-flat at the end of the glissando, being careful to hold the A-flat each time.  I find both approaches equally appealing.

mm. 26-29: This is a simple restatement of the opening chords leading to as close as this piece comes to a harmonic resolution in m. 30.  I play these very similarly to mm. 1-4.

mm. 30-33: These measures are remarkable because (as Roberts, p. 163, points out) the high melody contains notes that are in the very high and almost inaudible overtone sequence of the chords.  The are to be played very softly.  M. 30 is marked “very soft and very expressive”, while m. 32 is marked “even more soft”.  I use the soft pedal for the last two measures, applied slowly during the last two notes of m. 31.  The last three notes in the right hand, m. 32, are percussive and very soft, decreasing in volume until the last note is barely heard.  Roberts points out that this allows the listener to infer the final high D, held in the chord, which gives the piece an implied but not stated harmonic resolution.

Advertisements

4 comments on “Canope (Preludes, Book II, 1913)

  1. Mina says:

    I have just learned this prelude and find it very beautiful. Your website is very helpful (I played the Girl with the Flaxen Hair, Minstrels and Des Pas dans la Neige as well)! I have a specific question about this prelude. I cannot possible reach a 10-note chord and there are many in this prelude. I cannot make up about how to play them a) with the bottom note first and then the top 2 notes or b) rolled. I don’t think they should be rolled, because it easily becomes too lyrical for this piece. But playing them ‘broken’ risks loosing rhythm. What do you suggest? I bet you have huge hands, you don’t have this issue!

    • Andela says:

      I have the same problem with 10ths. I cannot even stretch most 9ths and have to play almost all octaves 1-5 despite e lot of stretching exercises. I believe some people do have hands that will never be able to reach a 10th no matter how much Hanon etc. is played. It is not only the length of the fingers (whih even my 10-12 year old girl students usually all surpass) but also the breadth of the palm. Both can be stretched to some extent (that’s why I can reach some 9ths) but not indefinitely. I am a professional composer and do quite a bit of corepetition. Thus, I often have to work out what to do about large chords. One option for 10ths can be to block the chord as an Octave and fill in the upper note. To make the chord soud a bit more “open” leave out a note that is present in another voice. For Canope in m.5 for example play D-F-d or D-A-d (sounds a bit better) instead. Or play D-A only, in m.14 C-E-c and F-A-c-f. It is not a perfect solution but in Canope ther is this “archaic” sound wich does not go too well with rolled chords – as you also mentioned 10 years ago :-). This however gets rid of the parallel 5ths which also contribute to the sound. Another way of getting the sound may be in m. 14 to do C-G-c, F-c-f and then playing e1 instead of c1 in the soprano voice. In general I experiment until the sound gets close to what I think it should be. As a composer I usually prefer a good interpretation of my intentions to one that has all the “right” notes but little expression because of technical struggling.

  2. steve says:

    Hi Mina – Thanks for your kind comments. I suppose you mean all those 5th + 10th left-handed chords in, say, m. 14. I can reach those, and my hands are not bigger than average. These chords are a stretch that I could not make back when I started playing, but I have been able to stretch my hands over the years. I have a professional pianist friend who has some of the smallest hands I’ve ever seen and she can make larger stretches.

    I don’t think it works to break these chords up, since they provide a solid yet soft and delicate foundation for what’s happening on top, but if you absolutely cannot make the stretch I would roll the chords, with the last note of the roll coinciding with playing the chord with the right hand. Sort of like make the last note of the previous measure and the bottom two notes of the lh chord into a fast triplet prior to the measure. But it’s better to train your hands for the stretch. Hanon exercises help.

    Or you can try the technique demonstrated at

    Good luck!
    steve

  3. copy dvd says:

    Prompt, where to me to learn more about it?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s